Friday, 8 February 2013

Given the proximity of Waitangi Day (6th of February) and the recent death of a radio and television broad caster, Paul Holmes (1st of February 2013), who last year wrote an opinion peice on the protests that typically accompany Waitangi Day, I was discussing this with a colleague at work and she brought up Parihaka as an example of the validity of the claims associated with those protests.

Parihaka & Chief Eruera Te Whiti

The archaeological sites in North Taranaki from 1860 to 1881 detail a long conflict between the New Zealand Government/ Colonial Government and Indigenous Maori Tribes (Prickett 1999 : 85). The significance of Historical Archaeology in New Zealand is that not only does it pose as a means to understand other ways of life, but also to examine the realities of historical processes. In New Zealand up until the middle of the 1970s Pakeha New Zealanders considered New Zealand as having a relatively unique harmonious bicultural heritage (Morris 2003). This perception of harmony was challenged by protests against land acquisition by the government and to investigate the validity of these claims, the Waitangi Tribunal was created in 1975 and from 1985 was a permanent commission of inquiry and this has lead or been part of a process of reexamining New Zealand history. During the 1990s visible government discourse contained statements about the idea of biculturalism and now (2013) there is a sense that New Zealand is no longer bicultural but is best described as multicultural.

Even so the Treaty of Waitangi stands as a founding document for the New Zealand nation and accords the representatives of around 540 Maori Tribes the " just rights and property of Maori and to secure to them the enjoyment of Peace and Good order" (Morris 2003)  while acceding governorship (Kawanatanga) to the British Colonial Government. This treaty, which was an agreement between the British Colonists and Indigenous Maori, was by 1877 declared by Chief Justice Prendergast in Supreme Court to be "a simple nullity" and Maori ownership of land was compromised through a number of processes, including confiscation of land from tribes in rebellion on the grounds of punitive measures and paying for the expense of military operations, as occurred from 1860 onwards during the Maori Land Wars (1860 to 1881). These rebellions were in part to resist land sales which were done according to Pakeha legal and cultural norms.


One of the topics of investigation of the Waitangi Tribunal were the events of Parihaka on the 5th of November 1881, which was covered in the Taranaki Report. This report was notorious for drawing implicit comparisons between events in Taranaki and the activities of the Nazis during the Second World War, but the events were quite bad enough not to require the comparison (Morris 2003). Essentially factions in the  Colonial New Zealand Government, pressured by Native Minister John Bryce, in a response to demand for land by settlers, engaged in military operations against passively resisting Maori residing in the Maori settlement of Parihaka.  Parihaka was a large successful Maori pa & town that was settled by Chief Eruera Te Whiti o Rongomai in 1867 at the close of the Second Taranaki War as a means to avoid association with either side and the potential violence, to maintain control of Maori Land and create a settlement based on religious principles and understood political realities. He was later joined by Tohu Kakhi and a close kinsman, Te Whetu. Thus the settlement incorporated multiple tribes and by the 1870's became a prosperous and productive town/ pa/ settlement with regular roads and occupational specialization. Chief Eruera Te Whiti is described as a prophet drawing inspiration from the Christian faith to council his followers to resist the colonial soldiers using non violent protest.

Te Whiti 1880, Sketch by William Francis Gordon




Chief Eruera Te Whiti is an interesting historical figure who can be argued to have provided a transitional belief system from Pai Marire to Orthodox Christianity (Gadd 1966 : 456). From a synchronic perspective it can be argued that Te Whiti over time synthesized a belief system incorporating the powerful engrammic motifs of indigenous Maori and Christian traditions that provided meaning and direction (hope) to the communities connected to Parihaka. In retrospect, that he is also seen as an "a Prophet" or religious leader may be in part due to the Colonial Government's need to represent him as a "deluded prophet, a madman or menace to the colony" (Riseborough 2010 : 235), thus being able to justify their repressive legislation as being in the Maori's best interests (Riseborough 2010 : 235).

The sources that seek to represent Te Whiti's thought have been criticized by Hazel Riseborough in "Days of Darkness : The Government and Parihaka, Taranaki 1878- 1884" as most interpreters working for the government and settler press subjected their interpretations to their own preconceptions and it was typical for the government to only accept interpreter reports when it fitted their own agendas.

Bernard Gadd in 1966 can be judged a sympathetic writer whose information sources included the sayings of Te Whti & Tohu as reported in the New Zealand Herald and Lyttelton Times of 1880 and 1881 as well as four references from Te Whiti's conversations with Cowan and Baucke and Te Whiti's testimony in court (Risenborough 1989 : 22). Risenborough criticised Gadd's lack of more direct sources, indicating that Gadd's evidence to characterise Te Whiti as a prophet and religious leader is insufficient (Risenborough 1989 : 22), what would be interesting is to compare the direct sources information to statements by Colonial leaders to see if there are a comparable statements formulated in a religious paradigm.

What can be stated are the influences of Te Whiti’s thought included the traditional Maori lore of his community, he was born in 1831 the son of Honi Kaakahi, a Ngatiawa chief, and Rangikawa, the daughter of a Taranaki chief and Christianity learned at the German Lutheran mission station of Riemenschneider at Warea, where he was baptised Eruera (Edward) and retained a life long Christian belief. On the 17th of March 1860 the Maori-Pakeha War began.

For Te Whiti and Tohu, both at the Reimenschneider mission school, the out break of war meant the closing of the Riemenschneider mission and the bombardment of the Warea pa from the sea (Rizeborough 2010 : 232). The campaign of Colonel Golds force was to damage the Maori economy of the area, on the 27th of April 1860 this force reached Warea, sacking the pa, destroying agriculture, food supplies and a flour mill and thus Te Whiti and Tohu were amongst the people going inland to escape the fighting. During this the experience of bloodshed, suffering, Pakeha greed for land, duplicity, land confiscations and the acquiescence of European missionaries to these processes would have left an impression on Te Whiti and in the resulting search for a credible belief system that provided meaning and relevance to his experience, he became involved in the indigenous Maori religion of Pai Marire. Te Whiti fought at the battle of Sentry Hill on April 30, 1864 with warriors influenced by the Pai Marire religion. The Pai Marire religion incorporated concepts found in Chrisitanity, using the symbol of god (Atu), the niu pole and the religious movement held that the key to Atu’s plan was found in the Bible. Although providing a focus for tribes to unite, the movement was eventually defeated in military terms by January 1865. Around 1866 Te Whiti settled at Parihaka and in 1868 Te Whiti had prevented his people from participating in a rebellion led by the Ngati Ruanui leader, Titokowaru (Gadd 1966 : 447).

Bernard Gadd (1996) describes Te Whiti’s concept of God was as something like a mighty impersonal force moving in and working itself out in history, whose will could be discerned and obeyed (Gadd 1966 : 447) . This concept was different from the intimate, personal relationship with God preached by most nineteenth century missionaries, who made no serious attempt to understand Te Whiti’s approach (Gadd 1966 : 447). To his Maori followers Te Whiti stressed the importance of suffering, as a expiation of sins but also as obedience to God's will, a kind of stoicism born of the belief that featured the renounciation of "desires" and acceptance that obedience to the will of god, that is in the end " to the benefit of the Maori people" (Gadd 1966 : 450). It is important to realise that Bernard Gadd is writing during the height of the geopolitical tensions described as the Cold War which had ideologies using political economic thought on both sides, and this description potentially has synthetic elements from popular 20th century political economic thought and Christianity. Bernard Gadd's evidence for this statement is the November 1907 New Zealand Herald (Gadd 1966 : 454). Also consider the common settler approach of the time,  that the Maori were a "breed dying out" and that "civilization provided their salvation" (Risenborough 1998 : 227). Although Origin of the Species was published in 1859, racial theories of selection were common, William Paley, who opposed the slave trade, published Natural Theology in 1809, it held that adaptation was a sign of "Gods" design. In the New Zealand Herald of November 1865, there is a letter submitted by J Giles discussing "Modern Scientific Theists" and the "unmistakable marks of supreme design" (Giles 1865). Thus in colonial New Zealand, ideas of social evolution, incorporating Christian religious thought, were there and thus he could have synthesized the ideas himself or been exposed to them through European advisors or contacts. 

Dreaming is often seen as having a prophetic function. Dreams are seen as a source of revelation in the Bible, in Genesis 41 the interpretation by Moses of Pharaoh's dream of years of fertility and famine , in Matthew 2:12, the Magi avoid returning to Herod because of a dream, and in Acts 2:17 "Your sons and daughters will prophesy, your young men will see visions, your old men will dream dreams", as a few examples. Thus there is an element of the function of religious prophet in a story associated with Dame Whina Cooper, who led coalition Maori groups during 1975 on a ceremonial hikoi, now described as the Maori Land March.

The story has Dame Whina Cooper having a dream that "She was walking along a road towards her relatives when she met God in the form of a man whose eyes flashed and flickered so that she could hardly look at him" (Bowater 2012 : 48). In this dream God tells her "Your work is not completed" and in the following year in 1975 Dame Whina lead the Maori Land March on the New Zealand Parliament, which was part of a process that ignited a renaissance of Maori culture that includes the Waitangi Tribunal (Bowater 2012 : 48).

Organizations

New Zealand Archaeological Association website 

Waitangi Tribunal

Websites that reflect the range of approaches discussing Parihaka.

Parihaka: New Zealand History

Victoria University: The Taranaki Frontier and the Expedition to Parihaka

 Taranaki Daily News: Parihaka Day deserves to be celebrated

Waitangi Tribunal: The Taranaki Report -Kaupapa Tuatahi Parihaka

Reading the Maps: Before Parihaka 

John Ansells "Treatygate", against movie Parihaka. In greater context appears to be against the Waitangi Tribunal.

John Ansell comments on "Parihaka Day plea gains momentum"

Bibliography

Bowater, Margaret. (2012). Dreams and Politics: How Dreams May Influence Political Decisions. In the Journal of Psychotherapy and Politics International, Volume 10, Issue 1. Pages 45 -54.

Gadd, Bernard. (1966). The Teachings of Te Whiti O Rongomai, 1831 -1907. In the Journal of the Polynesian Society, Volume 75, No 7. Pages 445 -457

Morris Ewan. (2003). History Never Repeats? The Waitangi Tribunal and New Zealand History. In History Compass, Volume 1, Issue1.

Prickett, Nigel. (1999) Archaeological site recording in New Zealand. Page 85. Available at http://nzarchaeology.org/elecpublications/ArchaeologicalSiteRecording_Part1.pdf. Last viewed 08/02/2013.

Riseborough, Hazel. (1989). Days of Darkness. The Government and Parihaka. Taranaki 1878 -1884. (Revised Edition). Published by Penguin Books Ltd. Printed  in Australia by McPherson's Printing Group. Pages 22 & 227.

Riseborough, Hazel. (2010). A New Kind of Resistance: Parihaka and the Struggle for Peace. (Edited by Kelvin Day). In Contested Ground Te Whenua I Tohea : The Taranaki Wars 1860 -1881. Published by Huia  Publishers. Printed in Thailand by Sirivatana Interprint Public Co Ltd. Pages 231 -254.

Tuesday, 29 January 2013

Reading "Islamic Land Tax - Al-Kharaj : From the Islamic Conquests to the 'Abbasid Period" by Ghaida Khazna Katbi (2010).

I am quite interested in the late Roman Empire and Rashidun period of the Middle East as there is a sense of massive change in what was before and what came after. At 629 AD the Eastern Roman Empire had just survived the Byzantine-Sassanid Wars, restored the true cross of Jerusalem and was the ascendant power in the Middle East and Eastern Europe with major in roads to Italy and the Visigothic Kingdom of Spain. After the Battle of Yarmouk in 636 AD the Eastern Roman presence in the Middle East ended and over the period of centuries the resulting conflict between the resultant political entities culminated in the Crusades and the capture of Constantinople by the Ottoman Turks in 1453.

In history what tends to be lost from the record is the experience of everyday people living their lives, archaeology is part of the process of investigating this, the issues they faced and the solutions they found to these issues.

The first chapter of  Ghaida Khazna Katbi's book, is titled the "Systemisation of Taxes under Umar bin al-Khattab". Umar bin al-Khattab  was the second caliph of the Rashidun Caliphate (ruling from 634 - 644 AD), who continued the wars of expansion while laying down the political foundations of the state, he set up the state apparatus for government and taxation and the toleration or maintenance of the culture of subject peoples in the conquered territories. During the conquest period commanders imposed a jizyah tax on non-muslims that was independent of land. The soldiers (muqatilah) during the conquest period saw much of the conquered land as spoils of war, while the Rashidun caliphate, in an effort to minimise harm, saw that the conquered land was left as the property of its original owners, who paid a kharaj, a land tax. These agreements were later systematized with distinctions between cultivated and uncultivated land, which bears a similarity to the Byzantine tax on head counts (tributum capitis) and tax on land (tributum soli) (Khazna Katbi 2010 : 31). By the 5th century AD Eastern Roman taxes on land, head count and property had merged to one tax, the iugum. The two seperate taxes imposed by the Rashidun caliphate emerged from the Islamic concepts of jizyah and fay, jizyah on head count of non Muslims and kharaj on the land (Khazna Katbi 2010 : 32).

In the Byzantine state peasants were linked to the land, as serfs, and taxed as part of a unit of land, thus in essence were property of the land owner and in service to the land owner. This seems similar in essence to slavery and thus the Rashidun Caliphate in considering them as free men, with an independent tax, may go to some degree in explaining the rapidity of the fall of the provinces of Syria and Egypt to the Rashidun Caliphate.

Chapter 2 Tax Measures under the Umayyads (661 - 750 AD).

Details the decrease in labor in Basra, movement of peasants (fallahun), plague and attempts to increase agricultural productivity. The Islamic dinar equaled the weight of the Byzantine solidus circulating in Syria, fixed weight of the dinar at weight of mithqal to prevent exploitation by tax collectors (Khazna Katbi 2010 : 77).

Chapter 3 Taxation under the Abbasids (750 -1258 AD).

Systematic influence of jurists (fuqahau), ministers (wuzara) and state officials (kuttab). Assessment of land in terms of its productivity (muqasamah), a proportional share cropping assessment system introduced instead of land area (kharaj). Around 786 -808 AD there was a desertion of great landowners from their estates in Palestine (Khazna Katbi 2010 : 127), it is theorized this was because of the kharaj imposed. New people were introduced and some of the lands were returned to the original owners.

In Damascus there was a revolt, lead by Abu al-Haydham al-Murri, over seven years during 786 -793 AD. The cause of the revolt is complex, it is seen as related to ownership of land around Damascus that had fractured along tribal lines, the Yamani controlled access to water and were forced by the state to distribute it, but further conflict arose. The rebellion can be characterized as a conflict between the semi-Bedouin Qaysi tribe and the rural Yamani tribe. Most of the tribes united behind the Qaysi tribe to expel or bring under control the rural Yamani tribe. Attempts at reconciliation were made, the state enticed the Yamani with wealth and equipment, the Yamani interpreted this as support for them by the state. The Yamani burnt Qaysi villages, the Qaysi retaliated and drove the Yamani tribes to a place called Bustan Atikah. Abu al-Haydham was successful in countering and opposing the Yamani raids, villages approached him for protection, a guarantee was made, the agreement describes the necessity of a unified effort to deal with common dangers and problems (Khazna Katbi 2010 : 130), this agreement was not acceptable to the state and thus the tribal conflict became a rebellion.

The governor of Damascus mobilized his army, of around 12000, to oppose Abu al-Haydham, besieging him at al-Bab al-Sharqui, the state army's general al-Adhafir was killed and thus attempts at reconciliation were made between the state and Qaysi. The Yamani of Homs exploited the peace negotiations to raid  villages and attack the Qaysi. The Qaysi response was violent, following the Yamani to the forts of Harlan and Habka and raised Yamani villages. The Yamani of Homs spread news of Abu al-Haydhams persistent disobedience to the state. The state used this as justification to create an army of around 20000 under the leadership of al-Sindi. Al-Sindi, from recommendations of a subordinate Bustam suggested negotiation with Abu al-Haydham, concessions were made and Abu al-Haydham withdrew 9000 horsemen to the village of Rawiya. The Yamani again attempted to incite the governor against Abu al-Haydham. The governor indicated the difficulty of military operations against Abu al-Haydham and is reported as saying "If you wanted to kill him, I would not have prevented you, but its best to avoid him. By my life, he is troublesome for you, so why don't you kill him" (Khazna Katbi 2010 : 131). The financial loss to the state of the rebellion was calculated by the loss of kharaj, damage to crops, devastation and plunder and the cost of military operations.

Chapter 4 The Administration and Systemisation of Taxes.

The discussion of the use of force in gathering taxes was discussed by tax collectors to the state,  communication from the state involves ideas of proportional taxation, maintaining justice and only taking the surplus of wealth for the kharaj, being "kind" (Khazna Katbi 2010 : 182), although harshness in the collection of the kharaj was prevalent. Functions of the treasury included the  maintenance and building of new canals and dams.

The harshness of the tax collectors was a problem that surfaced in the mazalim courts, levying became severe in some regions and were associated with revolts and confrontation.

Chapter 5 The Beginnings and Development of the Sawafi.

As Muslims began to own land the revenue from the kharaj decreased for the state. Sawafi was all land that did not have an owner at the time of conquest and was initially considered fay (property seized by force) for the soldiers (muqatilah). During the Rashidun Caliphate conquest of the Sassanid Empire, Umar al-Khattab dividing the land owned by the factions allied to Khusrau the 2nd for the state taking one fifth and the muqatilah taking four fifths and this set up a precedent. The Muqatilah for operational reasons  impounded the land  and gave it to the supervision of governors, it became collective property with revenue distributed to the muqatilah, this was to facilitate continuation of military operations  (Khazna Katbi 2010 : 234). Over time during the Ummayad caliphate it became a point of conflict between who owned the sawafi land, the muqatilah's governors or the caliphate, as the Sassanid concept was that the land was the property of the crown ( (Khazna Katbi 2010 : 238). As Muslims started to purchase land from the non Muslims (ahl al-dhimmah) this reduced the revenue from the sawafi and kharaj lands, The term taqabbul appears during the Umaayad caliphate sparsely, it refers to a cultivation contract between a liable Muslim and the state. During the Abbasid caliphate the idea of the states ownership of swafi land was firmly established and thus the swafi land became a stable source of revenue (Khazna Katbi 2010 : 258).

Chapter 6 The Legal Foundations of the Kharaj.

The kharaj was a land tax imposed on non Muslims, once a man converted the jizya, head tax was removed but the kharaj was continued . The basis for the imposition of the kharaj is based on the Quran "until they pay the jizyah by hand, and they are humbled (wa-hum saghirun) (from Qur'an, sural al-Tawbah (9:29) (Khazna Katbi 2010 : 279). It is argued  by the Hanafis (a school of Sunni Islamic legal thought) and Malikis (a school of Sunni Islamic religious thought) that Umar al-Khattib used independent reasoning (ijtihad) on the basis of public welfare (al-maslahah al-ammah) in designating the conquered land as common property (fay), where the orignal owners retain possession in exchange for paying the Kharaj  (Khazna Katbi 2010 : 277).

Al-Shafii, a Islamic jurist from the Abbasid caliphate argued that land conquered peacefully (sulh), where the occupants paid jizyah, remained the occupants property even if they were paying kharaj, they had rights to the land. Land conquered by force (unwah) could be either divided or made common property (fay), deriving precedence from the Sunnah or policies of Umar al-Khattib. Unused land (mawat) could be revived and the type of taxation imposed was dependent on the Muslim or dhimmah status of its occupants. Over time the kharaj imposed was dependent on the productivity of the land. Ownership of land was created from iqta grants of mawat land or sawafi, granted by caliphs and governors to followers and supporters  (Khazna Katbi 2010 : 300). The selling of unwah and kharaj land was generally disapproved by the Islamic law scholars of the time, but in reality the land was sold, at least until Umar the second, an Umayyad caliph (ruled 717 -720) who is associated with a number of legal and social reforms, including the removal of the jizya tax from converted Muslims.

Chapter 7 provides the names and descriptions of the original sources, such as Amr bin  Maymun who narrates Umar al-Khattabs taxation arrangements  (Khazna Katbi 2010 : 316).

In summary, the book uses original sources contemporaneous with the Rashidun (632 -661 AD), Ummayad (661 -750 AD) and Abbasid (750 -1258 AD) caliphates to detail the issues and solutions of the early Arabic states in raising revenue, and engaging in the development and maintenance of their infrastructure, while attempting to meet the demands of social justice as it was understood at the time. Although the topic of the book is about land tax, the al-kharaj, other forms of taxation are covered and my interest, as someone who does not have a government or legal background is the experience of ordinary people living in these historical societies.

Bibliography

Khazna Katbi, Ghaida. (2010).  Islamic Land Tax - Al-Kharaj : From the Islamic Conquests to the 'Abbasid Period. Published by I.B. Tauris & Co Ltd. In Association with The Centre for Arab Unity Studies. Printed by CPI Anthony Rower, Chippenham, UK. 410 Pages.


Friday, 25 January 2013

Red Country by Joe Abercrombie


Red Country is set in the fantasy world of Joe Abercrombie's First Law Trilogy, The Heroes and Best Served Cold, which typically puts fantasy tropes into a modern perspective. In the dedication to Red Country, Abercrombie writes "For Teddy And Clint Eastwood. But since Clint probably ain't that bothered. Mostly Teddy.", although I can't say precisely what the authors intention was, one of the merits of this series of books is the character development of the protagonists and antagonists. The feel of the characters tends to be analogous to the feeling one gets watching the character development in some classical and  more recent movies set as "Westerns", such as the modern classic "Unforgiven" (Director Eastwood 1992). Abercrombie's main characters tend to be antiheroes and in the fantasy setting the author uses,  he explores ethical and sociological issues, which tends to be a feature of the movies that Clint Eastwood has directed.

In the First Law Trilogy the traditional "good guys" are the Union, a medieval kingdom organized with a king and chancellors, that has as part of its internal security an "Inquisition" and a creation myth a featuring a Merlin type wizard called "Bayaz". The main characters of the First Law Trilogy would, in the traditional fantasy trope, be the just, brave and noble defenders of a shining Camelot, in the First Law trilogy the "heroic" characters are vicious, cowardly survivors of a corrupt and incompetent government with the Merlin wizard character appearing more a fraud than a powerful wizard of legend. There is an undercurrent of humor, in the contrast between what is with what should be. In "The Heroes" the Union finds itself fighting rebels in the Northern countries, the Union forces tend to be newly conscripted farm boys with crossbows and pikes against tough clansmen with bows and claymores fighting in their home forests. In Red Country the Union has been fighting the rebels in the cold periphery of its northern states and as part of its mop up operations it employs a mercenary company to operate in territories along and over its border. These territories are a hard scrabble to many but echo an incipient industrial revolution occurring in the Union and allow some to create communities away from the social structures of the Union.

Tolkien wrote with the spectre of the First and Second World Wars and the influence of the Norse, Volsunga and Beowulf sagas. In the Red Country, the  fantasy setting is descriptively violent but this tends to convey a sense of loss, perhaps echoing the quote from Unforgiven (1992) said by the character William Munny " It's a hell of a thing, killing a man. Take away all he's got and all he's ever gonna have". The  antagonists tend to have understandable, sometimes even noble motivations and the protagonists are flawed, which I find more psychologically interesting. The fantasy world setting of the books The Heroes and Red Country are sequential, leading from the First Law Trilogy, and thus can be seen as part of a related chain of books/ novels.  Red Country can be described as developing the themes of technological and social change, previously in the First Law Trilogy magic served as a metaphor for the dangers of technology . These themes challenge the trope of a medieval setting in the traditional fantasy genre and has a stronger convergence with our world view. It also fits in with themes contained in a Western/ Wild West genre and it can be argued Red Country merges the fantasy and western genres.

When I bought the book I was told by the salesman that it wasn't as good as the previous First Law Trilogy. I didn't really have any expectations, The Heroes is about describing the sides of a battle and can be argued to be an experiment by the author. Red Country can be described as a quest novel but thankfully instead of a quest focusing on a magic item be it magic sword or ring, is about something more psychologically relatable.

Bibliography

Abercrombie, Joe. (2012). Red Country. Published by Gollancz, London. Printed by  Griffin Press, Australia. 451 Pages.

Wednesday, 7 November 2012

Cycles of creation & destruction in a cartoon.

It seems that when adults write about watching “Phineas & Ferb”, a Disney animated series produced by Dan Povenmire and Jeff Marsh from February 2008 (Wikipedia November 2012) they generally make a category entitlement of “watching it with my children”.Well, I'm a thirty something year old male who once woke up one Saturday morning and switched on the TV and accidentally watched “Phineas & Ferb” and was surprised at how easy it was to watch. It seems to have fairly high production values, much of the humour involves wordplay and misapplying plot rules it creates over time and some of it is quite sophisticated for a kids show. So you may enquire “Aren't you too old to watch a Saturday morning kid's cartoon?” and I would respond “Yes, yes I am”.

I was wondering if there was any academic work on what I was watching. So far, I have found a journal article by Kit Johnson (Johnson 2012) that uses "Attack of the 50 Foot Sister", Season 2 Episode 3 as its insipiration for its title. The article studies fashion model visas. In the episode Candace rejects an offer of a modelling contract because it is "nothing more than a plot to make money by encouraging people to feel bad about themselves" (Johnson 2012 : 863).


 Two web articles of note on this topic are Matthew Belinke's Myopia of Childhood and Margaret O'Connell's The Mildly Mad Scientific World of Phineas and Ferb. Matthew Belinke in Myopia of Childhood argues that the world view of the cartoon is the world view of children but differs from a common plot in children's cartoons where the children know more of the big picture than adults as part of a fulfilment fantasy of outsmarting the adults (Belinke 2011). He argues that there are multiple worlds revolving around each other in the cartoon and that the kids manifest a childlike myopia in which they let the world take care of itself and focus on having fun (Belinke 2011), which is not a bad value orientation for its intended audience.


Margaret O'Connell in The Mildly Mad Scientific World of Phineas and Ferb contrasts the female characters in this cartoon to the female characters in the 1997- 2003 cartoon Dexter's Laboratory and finds that the female characters portrayed in Phineas & Ferb are generally more intelligent, complex and sympathetic characters (O'Connell 2012).


As a kids cartoon it has a high degree of predictability in the plot, in fact much of the humour is based around the consistent plot structure and the characters awareness of this, the characters almost break the third wall but not quite. The cleverness of the show is how each episode is a variation of recurring plot structure elements. Phineas and Ferb are step brothers whose genius level intellects complement each other to enable them to create fantastic technological creations, and Candace is their older step sister.

Each episode has the same plot structure,

  • Phineas and Ferb work out what they are going to do today (think of Pinky and the Brain, “What will we do today Pinky?” “Today we will try to take over the world!”).
  • Candace their older sister tries to find out what they are up to so she can bust them.
  • Phineas & Ferb meet their friends, Isabella, Baljeet & Buford. Isabella has a crush on Phineas and always asks “What ch'ya doing?”. They begin their project with their friends helping.
  • Perry the platypus finds a secret entrance to his spy base.
  • Phineas & Ferb ask “Where's Perry?”. Perry the platypus gets given his mission for the day by Major Monogram (“I'm Major Monogram, I'm on the big screen, I'm Major Monogram and I wear green” sung to the tune of the Man from UNCLE theme song).
  • Doofenshmirtz is always building a machine that is designated by what it does, a verb- inator, with the object of “taking over the tri-state area”. It is never “take over the world” and in several episodes he specifically states “you can't rule over the tri-state area if you destroy it” to other allies who don't get his objective. Part of the motivation for this is that Doofenshmirtz has a more successful, good looking brother who is the mayor of the “tri-state area” and Doofenshmirtz is jealous. In an episode Doofenshmirtz is trying to identify why he is always failing he recognises the common element, he is always building an “inator” so the next machine he has built is a “non-inator” (Series 3 Episode 3. Phineas's Birthday Clip O Rama). Hilarious.
  • The thing Phineas & Ferb create is always cool and fun and often epic in scale, thus obviously worth the attention of the boys mother and so Candace spends time trying to get the attention of the mother, who is called “Linda”.
  • Perry the Platypus gets caught in Doofenshmirtz's trap, Perry breaks out, something clever happens and Perry defeats Doofenshmirtz's scheme.
  • Linda the mother treats Candace as someone who has an obsessive compulsive disorder with regards to her brothers, and she probably does, she needs to “bust” her brothers. In season 2 episode 32 “The Best Lazy Day Ever” where her brothers take a rest, doing nothing bustable, it precipitates an existential crisis in Candace. Hilarious for a kids cartoon. Eventually in every episode Linda finally pays attention to Candace's entreaties and goes to look at what Phineas & Ferb are doing. Her experience of this is often a source of humor, is talked about as an issue with Candace and the mother tries to take steps to control this behaviour. For example, in Season 2 Episode 46, “Out of Toon” when Candace phones her mothers cell phone the answer phone message is “Please leave your psychotic rant about your brothers at the end of the beep”.
  • When Linda, the mother, finally looks at what Fineas & Ferb have been doing it is always too late. Their project and all evidence of it is removed, often this is due indirectly to the destruction of Dr Doofenshmirtz's “inator” by Perry the Platypus. Sometimes it becomes a less mind boggling approximation of what Candace is describing. For example in Season 2 Episode 9 “Chez Platypus”, the step brothers build a restaurant, when Candace finally gets Linda to look, the restaurant has disappeared leaving only tables and chairs and thus it looks like the step brothers and their friends have been playing restaurant.
  • Perry the Platypus reappears and Phineas or another character recognizes the return of Perry with a variation of the phrase “Oh,there you are Perry.”
There are generally two cycles of creation and destruction each episode. The boys in each episode are creating their project, it is like children playing but in the context of the cartoon what they make works to achieve fantastic results and it is fun. Candice the older sister is trying to police her brothers innocent creativity and invariably fails to obtain proof for the authority figure in the Phineas and Ferb cycle, which is Linda the mother. Their project invariably gets removed, destroyed or escapes by the time Linda the mother gets there to observe.

The second cycle of creation and destruction is between Perry the Platypus and Dr Doofenshmirtz, this is adults doing work, from a kids perspective (Belinke 2011). In this cycle Perry the Platypus is trying to police Dr Doofenshmirtz's machiavellian creativity. He is empowered by Major Monogram with the authority to police Dr Doofenshmirtz's creativity and succeeds, making the world safe. Once the scheme is foiled Perry returns to being Phineas and Ferb's pet at the end of the episode. Both Candace and Perry have "police" roles in the context of the cartoon but only Perry appears successful in his police role. Candace when she is not engaged in a policing role is often portrayed as obsessed with her relationship with Jeremy and doing teenage things with her friend Stacy. Her relationship with Jeremy is generally portrayed in a positive way and makes her a more sympathetic character as compared to simply being an antagonist. 

Thus there appears to be two entwined cycles in each episode, the innocent creativity of children which is unimpeded and the goal directed creativity of adults, which is impeded. I often wonder the degree that the world view of the episode writers intrudes, perhaps unintentionally into the episode.


Images from Wikipedia November 2012.


Adults as represented by a silent Platypus wearing a fedora and Dr Doofenshmirtz, a comic stereotype of an American German scientist. Ah well. These cycles are what is designated as plots and subplots by Margaret O'Connell (O'Connell 2012) and "multiple worlds revolving around each other" by Matthew Belinkie (Belinkie 2011).

Bibliography

Belinkie, Matthew. (September 2011). Phineas and Ferb: The Myopia of Childhood. @ http://www.overthinkingit.com/2011/09/15/phineas-and-ferb . Last viewed 5-11-2012.

Johnson, Kit. (2012). Importing The Flawless Girl. In the Nevada Law Journal. Volume 12. Pages 831 to 867.

O'Connell, Margaret. (October 2012). Mad Science for Girls (and Boys), Part 2: The Mildly Mad Scientific World of Phineas and Ferb. Published by Sequential Tart @ http://www.sequentialtart.com/article.php?id=2316 . Last viewed 8-11-12.

Wikipedia. (November 2012). Phineas and Ferb. @ http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phineas_and_Ferb . Last viewed 8-11-12.

Addendum (24/4/2019)

It is interesting how interpretation of a subject changes with observation over time. The creators of Fineas & Ferb (2007), Dan Povenmire & Jeff "Swampy" Marsh have developed a new TV series called Milo Murphy's Law (2016) which is set in the same fictional setting of Fineas & Ferb, in the Tri-state area. I found a video (2019) called Phineas & Ferbs Holistic Universe by some guy calling himself Quinton, that despite its pretentious tone I found interesting. It discusses plots, characters, differences and similarities of the two shows.



Saturday, 20 October 2012


Lifeline (1959) Interview : “Mars and Venus speak to Earth.”
 

Lifeline was a medical interview program made by the BBC and produced by Hugh Burnett during 1957 to 1959. In “Mars and Venus speak to Earth” the interviewer has George King, a taxi driver who founded the Aetherius Society describe being contacted by “The Space people”, plays a recording of his mothers description of a “flying saucer” and demonstrate a “trance” in which Mr King in a monotone voice contacts a space person “Aetherius from Venus” to deliver a message, which may have been a part of George King's motivation in appearing on the show.

The programme then has an Astronomer “Dewhirst” present his perspective on the abnormal account and then a Jungian psychiatrist interprete symbolically the significance of Mr Kings abnormal account. The program functions as part of a dominant discourse of Science that phenomena can be investigated rationally and explained using Science. 
 
There are a number of power relationships evident in the medical interview program, Mr King is exposed to public scrutiny and compelled to provide evidence for his world view while the psychiatrists remain anonymous due to category entitlements of their profession and subject his account to the Scientific Discourse of Astronomy and Psychiatry circa 1959. He is treated as an object of enquiry, made very much part of an outgroup, with the dominant ingroup being the scientists. Part of this scientific discourse is the value of impartiality, thus Mr King is invited to provide a trance, which I would argue is form of display in the spiritualist tradition, he speaks in a monotone, the intonation is supposed to convey otherwordliness and tries to evoke the transmitted entity as being superior and benevolvent, Aetherius refers to the interviewer as “my friend”. The interviewer questions Mr King as the transmitted intelligence Aetherius, asks him “ Where are you speaking from now?” around 17 minutes, 47 seconds into the program (I, 17:47), Mr Kings reply as Aetherius is “I am sorry my dear friend, I cannot answer that question for you”. Mr King is invoking a resistance discourse, the Scientific fallibility discourse, that Science does not know everything and thus there are limits to the human ability to account for abnormal experience. This counter discourse is apparent in Mr Kings attempt to account for the construction of “flying saucers” indicating that they are made of an “organic metal” around 7 minutes 22 seconds and that it has a “living cellular structure”.

The topic flow of the interview is controlled by the interviewer, with the interviewer making interrogations, repeating the points he wants to make . Cohesion is maintained in Mr Kings account by anaphoric reference using “it's” and “it is” which occurs in many of the utterances of the scientists. When the interviewer invites Dewhirst the Astronomer to “deal” with Mr Kings account of the construction of a flying saucer Dewhirst indicates “Mr King and I are not speaking the same language” around 23 minutes in the program and indicates the lexical item “organic metals” is completely meaningless. Thus Mr King is clearly speaking a inferior language variety in the context of the program. Part of the problem is that Mr King is trying to use the Dominant Scientific discourse to provide validity to his account against ingroup Scientists. They function as gatekeepers in this program for what constitutes scientific truth. Mr King in using the lexical item “organic metals” is using two mutually exclusive concepts in a dialectical way to indicate the material is a synthesis of these two mutually exclusive concepts. Mr Dewhirst the Astronomer, a member of the dominant ingroup of scientists refuses to acknowledge it as a lexical item. Both the scientists and Mr King are trying to evoke truth values consistent with the Dominant Scientific discourse, the value of empirical observation but Mr Kings evidence is based on flawed testimony and cannot be falsified as it has a heavy religious component thus the scientists describe him as “sincere but deluded” and thus provide an account for Mr Kings actions, that is representative social issues of the time.

The interviewer and other scientists speak a formal scienfic Oxford English register and use forms of politeness and titles when referring to each other. Politeness and impartiality aside I am inclined to wonder how nice it is to be subjected to investigation and described as “sincere but deluded”. Mr King had an agenda and the scientists referred to him as Chairman of the Aetherius Society. Thus there must have been reasons for Mr King to maintain involvement with this program, possibly psychological and esteem based. He eventually became a cult leader and the Aetherius Society is an  established UFO religion.
 
The 1959 TV broad cast is also referenced in a documentary "TV's Believe it or not", describing the development of TV broadcasts over time. The interview is described as an example of the bizarre content of early TV programs. .   

Saturday, 29 September 2012

Tom Brown's Schooldays and the Olympic Games

Before the first modern Olympic games, held in Athens in 1896, there were regional “Olympic festivals” motivated by various ideologies and consisted of an amalgam of sports, for example, the 1850 Wenlock Olympic Class, a small village in Shropshire had tilting, football, quoits, cricket and fun events such as a wheelbarrow race (Toohey 2007 : 32).

The motivation for holding the Olympic festivals involved a valuing of the perceived glory of the ancient world and a belief of the intrinsic values of playing sport, often associated with a militant nationalism, such as "fitter men of the nation will mean the nation is more successful at war", for example. The Olympic ideal was that people were motivated to  play sport due to its intrinsic benefits, thus the compeditors were amateurs. It was associated with a “Muscular Christianity” which held the value of “a sound mind in a sound body”, comparable to the ideals of moral and physical development found in “Tom Browns Schooldays” by Thomas Hughes, a ex-pupil of Thomas Arnold, headmaster of Rugby School who extolled the virtues of “Muscular Christianity” (Toohey 2007 : 31). The Ideal of Olympianism is a philosophy of life, exalting and combining in a balanced whole the qualities of body, will and mind. It blends sport with culture and education. Creating a way of life based on the joy found in effort, educational value of good example and respect for universal fundamental ethical principles (Toohey 2007 : 42). Thus the early Olympic festivals were attempting to revive a somewhat fictional memory of the Greek Olympic games that were to embody the “Muscular Christianity” found in “Tom Browns Schooldays”.

The Modern Olympics grew out of the correspondences of individuals holding local “Olympic” events and the first attempt to internationalise the “Olympic” festivals was Dr Brooks of the Much Wenlock Olympics in 1881 who attempted to organise an Olympic festival in Athens. This attempt failed but the Frenchman Baron Pierre de Coubertin, who met Dr Brooks in 1890 while organising an international congress on Physical Education managed to fashion a Olympic revival which culminated in the 1896 Olympic games in Athens.

Hosting the Olympics Games is now seen as a great opportunity for revenue, economic development and urban renewal (Shoval 2002 : 584) and since the 2008 Olympic games has become a “mega event” (Gold & Gold 2008 : 300) thus there is much competition amongst potential hosts. For the initial Modern Olympic games held in Athens in 1896 the instructions were written in French, at the time French had a history of being the language of diplomacy and high culture within Europe and thus had significant linguistic capital. The London bid for the 2012 Olympic Games won over the Paris bid in July 2005. The London bid won in terms of the cultural resources that London could bring, comedians, actors, monarchy with a rhetoric of urban renewal and infrastructural development to areas of the city.

For the 2012 Olympic games, French was selected to be one of the official languages of the 2012 Olympic games, it was used to introduce the games, it took precedence during the presentation of medals and was used in other ceremonies, was present on “billboards and pageantry” and used for signage and commentary. This was a requirement imposed by the International Olympic Committee (IOC) as part of the conditions for hosting the 2012 Olympic games. The motivations behind this may reflect an awareness of the linguistic dominance of English, thus attempt to introduce a degree of linguistic pluralism and also be a nod toward the history of the Olympic games.
Bibliography

Gold, John R. & Gold, Margaret M. (2008). Olympic Cities: Regeneration, City Rebranding and Changing Urban Agendas. In Geography Compass. Volume 2, 5. Pages 300 -318.
Shoval, N. (2002). A new phase in the competition for the Olympic Gold: the London and New York bids for the 2012 Games. In the Journal of Urban Affairs. Volume 24, 5. pages 583 -599 

Toohey, K & Veal, A.J. (2007). The Olympic Games: A Social Science Perspective. Published By CAB international. Pages 31 & 42.

Tuesday, 11 September 2012